Newt Gingrich last week got politically slammed for proposing a Moon colony while campaigning in the Florida primary. In an obvious bid for votes from space coast residents Newt Gingrich claimed he would build a permanent colony on the Moon by the end of his second term. Sounds great if you’re a science fiction fan and space enthusiast, but everyone else just hears more national debt. The other Republican candidates quickly thrashed Gingrich for being impractical.
Even if the United States was flushed with dough and out of debt would Americans really want to return to the Moon? China is making plans to land on the Moon but will they develop a colony there when we didn’t? Back in 1969-1972 the U.S. landed six missions on the Moon, but the public grew bored after two. The Chinese will discover the same thing – only a geologist can love the Moon up close.
Sending humans to the Moon, or Mars or anywhere else in space just doesn’t make sense right now, and hasn’t since 1972. Sadly, robots have turned out to be far better astronauts, but we shouldn’t feel too choked up over being replaced by machines. The human body isn’t suited for life in outer space, at least not yet, whereas robots can thrive in the harsh climates beyond our atmosphere.
What we need to do is colonize the Moon with robots. Have machines roam over the lunar surface high and low and make a complete survey of natural resources. Then send robots that mine those resources and build other robots. Eventually we’d have enough robots on the Moon that could build underground cities suitable for humans to visit or colonize. Whether humans can live on the Moon for extended stays, reproduce, and safely raise children is still unknown. We may yet discover that humans can’t adapt to low gravity.
My point though is robots can build a colony on the Moon far cheaper than using manpower. And it would be a far greater scientific achievement to develop a robotic colony because most of the money and resources used for a lunar colony for humans would go just to keep people alive.
There are few reasons to go to the Moon:
- Scientific study of the Moon
- Base for very large telescopes
- Mine helium-3 when fusion reactors come online
- Prove that humans can live permanently in space
Three of the four reasons can be handled by robots, and robots could prepare the Moon for humans for the fourth.
Building a robot civilization on the Moon would be a new accomplishment and would outclass anything the Chinese could do by just repeating the Apollo missions.
Building a robotic colony would be far cheaper and it would lay the foundation for a cheaper human colony in the future.
Finally, developing the technology for a robotic civilization on the Moon would be more valuable than the accomplishment of putting men and women on the Moon again.
JWH – 1/31/12